It very much depends – and often the most tax efficient way of paying yourself is a combination of salary, dividends and perhaps even pension contributions, in order to maximise any allowances available.
Salary
A salary is a payment made to someone as an employee, through the PAYE system. It is a tax-deductible expense of the company and can, therefore, help reduce the amount of corporation tax payable, and can also be paid out irrespective of profit levels.
For the employee, amounts not covered by personal tax-free allowances, attract income tax at a rate of between 20 per cent and 45 per cent. National Insurance is also payable by both the employer and employee. However, if paid at the right level, a salary can help gain qualifying years for state pension purposes.
Dividends
Dividends are a share of a company’s profits and are paid to the shareholders in proportion to the shares that they hold. Unlike a salary, dividends are paid after corporation tax is deducted, and are therefore not a tax-deductible expense.
Dividends do attract a lower rate of income tax (8.75 per cent to 39.35 per cent) compared to a salary, and neither the employee nor employer pays National Insurance on dividend payments. There is also a personal tax-free allowance, meaning the first £2,000 of dividend income is tax free.
However, dividend payments can only be paid out if profits have actually been generated, so if there is no retained, or accumulated profits, then no dividend payment can be made.
Pension Contributions
Although not a substitute for salary and dividends, the third way of extracting funds is by means of a pension contribution paid directly from the company, as an employer’s contribution.
Employers pension contributions do not form part of your income, and therefore don’t incur an income tax liability, but are tax deductible by the company, meaning a saving on Corporation Tax.
There are however annual limits to what can be paid into your pension by an employer (currently a maximum of £40,000 depending on income), and also you wouldn’t be able to access the fund until at least the age of 55.
Conclusion
There is no one size fits all answer, and very much depends on the profitability of the company and personal circumstances.